WORK THROUGH A REAL TASK

How to Review an RFP for Missing Evidence

A worked evidence matrix, a local review worksheet, and a source-checking method before you draft a bid.

Prepared for InriGPT by Inri Inc · Updated 27 October 2026 · Fictional practice material

A bid can sound convincing while missing a mandatory requirement. Before drafting, build an evidence matrix: one buyer requirement per row, a source that supports it, an accountable owner, and a decision about what still needs work. This guide follows a small fictional support-services RFP all the way from the request to a submission decision.

1. Separate what the buyer asks from what you can prove

Our sample buyer asks for a named support lead, a rollout schedule, a security overview, and proof of an applicable certification. The supplier has a support rota and an old security summary. There is no schedule or certificate in the supplied material. A previous proposal saying “we meet all requirements” does not close either gap.

Keep the buyer wording intact. “Provide a certificate” is different from “describe your quality process.” Mark whether each item is mandatory, the requested format, and the submission deadline. Split a sentence containing several independently testable obligations into separate rows. Give each row a stable ID so reviewers can discuss R3 without copying a whole paragraph.

2. Review the sample matrix

ID / requirementEvidence decisionNext action
R1 · Named support leadVerified: support rota v3, section 2Check that the named person can cover this contract.
R2 · Rollout scheduleMissing: no schedule suppliedDelivery lead prepares a dated plan for approval.
R3 · Security overviewNeeds review: supplied summary is oldSecurity owner checks the current scope and replaces outdated statements.
R4 · Certification evidenceMissing: no certificate suppliedCompliance owner confirms whether the requirement can actually be met.

Only one of the four rows is verified: 1 ÷ 4 × 100 = 25% coverage. All four sample requirements are mandatory, so three still need attention. This is a record of your review decisions, not a prediction of winning, a compliance certification, or a claim that the bid is eligible.

3. Complete the evidence worksheet

Use the sample or paste up to 20 requirements, one per line. Add a source and owner, then deliberately choose each review status. The worksheet does not inspect documents or decide whether evidence is true. It counts the decisions you make and exports them for a reviewer. It runs on this page without an account or AI request. Use sample or redacted information; save your CSV before leaving.

Changes stay in page memory. This worksheet does not submit a bid, store your evidence, or use an AI provider.

4. Give an assistant a bounded drafting task

Once the evidence exists, use a narrow prompt. For example:

REQUIREMENT R1: Name the support lead.
APPROVED SOURCE: Support rota v3, section 2 names a support lead.
TASK: Draft a response using only the approved source. Quote the supporting passage separately. Flag missing scope or availability information. Do not invent a name, certificate, deadline, or commitment.

In a real request, include the actual approved passage rather than the abbreviated note above. Compare names, numbers, scope, and dates with that passage. A source title alone does not give the assistant access to the file. The public proposal demo accepts bounded material and has shared request limits; this local worksheet does not use that allowance.

5. Make the submission decision outside the draft

Missing mandatory evidence should reach the bid owner before the response is polished. The right action might be to obtain the source, ask the buyer a clarification question, disclose an exception where permitted, or decline to bid. A tool cannot grant permission to misstate eligibility. Keep the original request, evidence versions, reviewer names, and approval together in your own records.

Before submission, check that every mandatory row has an accountable decision, every factual sentence has a current source, attachments are included, and the final file obeys the buyer’s format and deadline. Useful AI assistance makes these gaps visible; it does not turn missing evidence into a fact.

Keep working with the source

Browse the other guides and practice files. Read our editorial approach or report an error. Examples demonstrate a method; they are not customer testimonials or measured business outcomes.